Violin Concerto: Recordings: Finale Cuts

Revision as of 16:53, 2 March 2019 by Brett (talk | contribs) (1 revision imported)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

The following table shows in detail per recording the cuts made in the Finale. Recordings without cuts are omitted.

Auer recommended the cuts 1 to 6. As cut 4a does not fit to the orchestral accompaniment, usually the shorter cut 4b is used.

Cut 1: Main theme cut by 12 bars (bar 69 – 80)
Cut 2: Main theme cut by 12 bars (bar 259 – 270)
Cut 3: cut of 8 bars (bar 295 – 298 & 305 – 308)
Cut 4a: cut of 10 bars (bar 421 – 430)
Cut 4b: cut of 8 bars (bar 423 – 430)
Cut 5: Main theme cut by 12 bars (bar 69 – 80)
Cut 6: cut of 4 bars (bar 580 – 583)

After the introduction with a short cadenza, the concerto is divided into three parts followed by a short orchestral intermezzo and the coda. All 3 parts start with the principal theme in D major, which made it easily possible to omit one of these parts.

Part 1: cut of 190 bars (bar 53 – 242)
Part 2: cut of 218 bars (bar 243 – 459)
Part 3 incl. orchestral intermezzo: cut of 104 bars (bar 460 – 563)
Begin of part 3: cut of 48 bars (bar 460 – 507)
Orchestral Intermezzo: cut of 24 bars (bar 540 – 563)

These cuts were so popular that only 4 of 170 recordings use different cuts.

Violinist Cut 1 Cut 2 Cut 3 Cut 4a Cut 4b Cut 5 Cut 6 Cut Part 1 Cut Part 2 Cut Part 3 Cut Begin of Part 3 Inter- mezzo Bars cut
(Pagani)/Libert X X X X X 52
(Wöbbel)/Havagesse X X X X X 52
Accardo/Rossi [1961] X X X X X 52
Adam/Shallon [1988] X X X 36
Aharonian/Krimets [1996] X X X X X 52
Amoyal/Dutoit [1981] X X X X X X 56
Andrade/Walther X X X X X 52
Anghelescu/Placidi [1995] X X X X X 52
Antonello/Greenberg X X X X 44
Auclair/Wagner X X X X X X 56
Bell/Ashkenazy X X X X 44
Cerkov/Radtke X X X X X 52
Cerkov/Albert X X X X X 52
Cerkov/Scigalsky X X X X X 52
Chang/Davis [1992] X X X X X 52
Chen/Kogan [1995] X X X X X 52
Chung/Previn [1970] X X X X X 52
Chung/Giulini [1973] X X X X X 52
Croitoru/Bardon [1988] X X X X X 52
Dauth/Iwaki [1994] X X X X X 52
Denhoff/Soltesz [2010] X X X X X 52
Fodor/Leinsdorf [1974] X X X X X 52
Fontanarosa/Petitgirard [1991] X X X 36
Francescatti/Rodzinski [1943] X X X X X X 56
Francescatti/Mitropoulos [1954] X X X X X 52
Francescatti/Munch [1958] X X X X X 52
Francescatti/Schippers [1965] X X X X X 52
Francescatti/Kletzki [1970] X X X X X 52
Frang/Gullberg Jensen [2011] X X 24
Friedman/Ozawa X X X X 44
Fujikawa/Waart X X X X X X 56
Funke/Vonk X X X X X 52
Garrett/Pletnev [1997] X X X X X 52
Gavrilov/Brückner-Rüggeberg X X X X X 52
Gitlis/Dixon [1961] X X X X X X 56
Gitlis/Mander [1965] X X X X X X 56
Gluzman/Litton [2007] X X X X X 52
Green/Greenburg X X X X X 52
Haendel/Cameron [1946] X X X X X X 56
Haendel/Goossens [1953] X X X X X X 56
Haendel/Müller-Kray [1960] X X X X X 52
Heinrici/Westergard X X X X X 52
Holmes/Maga X X X X X 52
Ishikawa/Kosler X X X X X 52
Josefowicz/Marriner X X X X X 52
Kantorow/Watanabe [1977] X X X X 44
Kim/Freeman [1993] X X X X X 52
Kim/Wordsworth [2013] X X X 36
Kino/Wit [1991] X X X X X 52
Klimov/Eliasberg X X X X X 52
Körner/Radtke X X X X X 52
Kogan/Gauk X X X X X 52
Kogan/Nebolsin [1950] X X X X X 52
Kogan/Vandernoot [1956] X X X X X 52
Kogan/Silvestri [1959] X X X X X 52
Korcia/Kantorow [2011] X X X X X 52
Kremer/Kitaenko X X X X 44
Kulenkampff/Rother [1939] X X X X 44
Lubotsky/Volmer X X X X X 52
Menuhin/Fricsay [1961] X X X X X 52
Meyer/Groth X X X X X 52
Midori/Abbado [1995] X X X X X 52
Milstein/Steinberg [1959] X X X X X 52
Milstein/Martinon [1969] X X X X X 52
Milstein/Abbado [1972] X X X X X 52
Muto/Stiefel [2003] X X X X X X 56
Mutter/Karajan [1988] X X X X X 52
Mutter/Previn [2003] X X X X 44
Nabakov/Usedruuf X X X X X 52
Nikkanen/Simonov [1990] X X X X X 52
Novak/Starek X X X X X 52
Odnoposoff/Goehr X X X X X X 56
Ojstrach/Gauk X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Konwitschny X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Kletzki [1955] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Kondrasin X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Skrowaczewski [1957] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Ormandy [1959] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Dervaux [1960] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/del Mar [1960] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Kempe [1963] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Rozdestvenskij [1968] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Sostakovic [1972] X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Ojstrach X X X X X 52
Ojstrach/Schüchter [1957] X X X X X 52
Paraschkevov/Tabakov [1996] X X X 36
Pasquier/Leducq-Barome [2007] X X X X X 52
Pauk/Staern X X X X 44
Pelassy/Rezucha [1995] X X X X X 52
Perlman/Wallenstein X X X X X 52
Perlman/Ormandy X X X X 44
Perlman/Mehta [1990] X X X X 44
Rabin/Fjeldstad [1964] X X X X X 52
Ricci/Seurre X X X X 44
Ricci/Sargent [1961] X X X X X 52
Rosand/Froment X X X X X 52
Salerno-Sonnenberg/Alsop [2004] X X X X X 52
Schaeffer/Narrato X X X X X 52
Shkolnikova/Kondrasin X X X X X 48
Shkolnikova/Simon [1986] X X X X 44
Sitkovetzky/Andre X X X X X 52
Spivakovsky/Goehr X X X X 44
Stern/Bernstein X X X X 44
Stern/Ormandy [1958] X X X X 44
Stern/Rostropovic [1977] X X X X 44
Szeryng/Dorati X X X X X X 56
Szeryng/Haitink X X X X X X 56
Szeryng/Munch [1959] X X X X X X 56
Szeryng/Mehta [1982] X X X X X X 56
Takezawa/Fedoseyev [1990] X X X X X 52
Ughi/Sanderling [1980] X X X X X 52
Ughi/Andreae [1981] X X X X X 52
Vanessa-Mae/Bakels [1991] X X X X X 48
Vinnikov/Menuhin [1994] X X X X X 52
Waiman/Rozdestvenskij [1971] X X X X X 52
Wanami/Fistoulari X X X X X 52
Watanabe/Sargent [1954] X X X X X X 56
Xue-Wei/Accardo X X X X X 52
Yao/Tan [1991] X X X X X X 56
Yaron/Soudant X X X X X X 56
Yonetani/Rezucha [1998] X X X X X 52
Zarins/Sinaisky X X X 36
Zukerman/Dorati X X X X X 52
Zukerman/Kubelik [1969] X X X X X 52
Zukerman/Mehta X X X X X 52
Accardo/Albert X X X X X X 76
Auclair/Wöss X X X X X X 234
Brown/Weissmann [1924] X X X X X 157 [1]
Bulov/Toscali X X X 242
Elman/Barbirolli [1929] X X X X X X 94
Elman/Paray [1945] X X X X X X 94
Elman/Ormandy X X X X X X 94
Elman/Boult [1954] X X X X X X 94
Ferras/Silvestri [1957] X X X X X X X 116
Ferras/Jochum [1964] X X X X X X 92
Ferras/Karajan [1965] X X X X X X 92
Ferras/Bruck [1968] X X X X X X 92
Gavrilov/Walther X 32 [2]
Gitlis/Hollreiser X X X X X X 148
Heifetz/Barbirolli [1937] X X X X X X 92
Heifetz/Steinberg [1949] X X X X X X 92
Heifetz/Susskind [1950] X X X X X X 92
Heifetz/Reiner [1957] X X X X X X 92
Huberman/Steinberg [1928] X X 198
Huberman/Ormandy [1946] X X 214
Menuhin/Fricsay [1949] X X X X X X 254
Milstein/Stock [1940] X X X X X 144
Milstein/Munch [1953] X X X X X 144
Milstein/Cluytens [1953] X X X X X 144
Milstein/Ancerl [1962] X X X X X X 76
Morini/Stravinskij [1940] X X X X X 144
Morini/Defauw [1945] X X X X X 144
Morini/Fricsay [1952] X X X X X 144
Morini/Rodzinski [1956] X X X X X 144
Morini/Horenstein [1957] X X X X X 144
Ojstrach/Samosud X X X 242
Olof/Pesek X X X X 98 [3]
Piastro/Barbirolli [1942] X X X X 246
Posselt/Burgin [1944] X X X X 80
Prihoda/Austin [1949] X X X X 68
Rabin/Galliera X X X X X 144
Ricci/Fournet X X X X 80
Ricci/Sargent X X X X X X 56
Schulz/Abendroth X X 116 [2]
Stern/Hilsberg [1949] X X X X X 68
Stern/Maazel [1958] X X X X X 68
Varga/Auberson X X 60
Wicks/Steinberg [1953] X X X X X 144
Wolf/Jensen X X X 222
Kraggerud/Zollman [1992] X X X X X X 56
Rabin/Voorhees [1960] X X X X X 52
Ricci/Voorhees [1964] X X X X X 52

Notes and References

  1. Additional cuts of 75 bars (bar 53-124 & 145-147).
  2. 2.0 2.1 Principal theme cut by 8 bars.
  3. Principal theme cut by 4 bars.